Blogs

NY Style vs Sicilian vs Grandma Pizza — The Ultimate Guide to Finding Your Perfect Slice | Nino’s Pizzeria

May 23, 2026 ◆ 6 min read ◆ Nino’s Pizzeria

ny style vs sicilian pizza

Walk into most pizzerias around Patchogue and you’ll see a few different styles on the board: NY slice, Sicilian, Grandma, maybe Neapolitan or even Detroit. They’re not the same thing, and each one’s good for something different.

The question we hear most at the counter is about NY style vs Sicilian pizza. So here’s our plain-English guide from Nino’s Pizzeria in Patchogue. We’ll cover what makes each style different and when you’d want to order it.

NY-Style Pizza: The Classic New York Pie

The shape: A big, thin, round pie, hand-stretched and cut into triangle slices you can fold.

The crust: Crisp on the bottom, chewy in the middle. It’s got just enough give to fold in half, which is how most people on Long Island eat it.

The sauce: Simple tomato sauce. Not sweet. Spread out close to the edge.

The cheese: Usually low-moisture mozzarella spread evenly over the sauce, melted until the edges turn golden.

The history: NY-style pizza came out of New York City in the early 1900s. Italian immigrants took the pizza they knew from Naples and changed it to work in American ovens. By the middle of the century, the slice shop was part of everyday life all over the tri-state area.

When to order it: Pretty much any time. It’s the everyday pizza, and a cheese or pepperoni pie covers most nights. Our cheese pie is $16.95, and a regular slice is $3.

Sicilian Pizza: The Thick Square

When you put NY style vs Sicilian pizza side by side, you see the difference right away.

The shape: Square or rectangular, and thick. Often an inch or more.

The crust: A lot like focaccia. Soft and airy inside, with a crisp bottom from the oiled pan.

The sauce: Often heavier than NY-style. Sometimes it goes on top of the cheese instead of under it.

The cheese: Plenty of mozzarella. Some Sicilian pies add ricotta or other cheeses too.

The history: It traces back to sfincione, a thick bread-style pizza from Sicily. Immigrants brought it over in the early 1900s and it got heartier over here.

When to order it: When you want something filling. It’s great for a group or a football Sunday. Our Cheese Siciliana is $23.95, and a Sicilian slice is $3.50. Feeding a bigger crowd? Take a look at our pizza catering options.

Grandma Pizza: A Long Island Original

You can’t talk about New York pizza types without Grandma pizza. It’s a Long Island thing.

The shape: Square, like Sicilian, but a lot thinner. Usually under an inch.

The crust: Thin and crisp. The dough gets pressed into an oiled pan instead of tossed, and the bottom comes out golden and crunchy. That crunch is the whole point.

The sauce: Crushed or chunky tomato, often spooned on top of the cheese.

The cheese: Mozzarella under the sauce. A lot of Grandma pies also get garlic, basil and a drizzle of olive oil.

The history: The story goes that it started in Long Island home kitchens, with Italian grandmothers baking pizza in sheet pans in regular home ovens. Over time it showed up on pizzeria menus across Nassau and Suffolk.

When to order it: When you want a thin crust like NY-style but with the square shape and crunchy bottom of a pan pie. A lot of people say it’s their favorite once they try it. Our Grandma pie is $20.

Neapolitan Pizza: Where It All Started

The shape: Round and small, usually a personal size.

The crust: Thin in the center with a puffy, charred edge called the cornicione. Traditionally it bakes in about 60 to 90 seconds in a very hot oven, often 900 degrees or more.

The sauce: Crushed tomatoes and salt. That’s about it.

The cheese: Fresh mozzarella, torn into pieces instead of shredded.

The history: This is the original. It comes from Naples, Italy, going back to the 1700s. In 2017, UNESCO added the art of Neapolitan pizza-making to its Intangible Cultural Heritage list.

When to order it: It’s best eaten right away, since it softens fast once it leaves the oven. At Nino’s, if you’re in the mood for something lighter, try our Neapolitan white pie ($22) or the Margherita ($24.95).

Detroit-Style Pizza: The Deep Rectangle

The shape: Thick and rectangular, baked in a steel pan.

The crust: Thick but light, with crispy corners. The cheese goes right to the edge of the pan and caramelizes against the sides. That crunchy cheese edge is what it’s known for.

The sauce: Ladled in stripes on top of the cheese.

The history: It started in Detroit in the 1940s. For years it was a local thing, and in the last decade or so it’s caught on all over the country.

When to order it: If you see it somewhere and haven’t tried it, give it a shot. It’s not common on Long Island, so it’s worth trying when you find it.

Quick Cheat Sheet: Pizza Styles at a Glance

  • NY-style: thin, round, foldable. The everyday slice.
  • Sicilian: thick, square, airy. The filling one.
  • Grandma: thin, square, crunchy bottom. The Long Island original.
  • Neapolitan: small, charred edge, soft middle. The Italian classic.
  • Detroit: thick, square, crispy cheese edges. The Midwest one.

The Pizza Styles You’ll Find at Nino’s in Patchogue

At Nino’s Pizzeria in Patchogue, you can try several of these styles in one place:

  • NY-style round pies, plain or with toppings (cheese $16.95, most one-topping pies $18.95)
  • Cheese Siciliana ($23.95) and Grandma pie ($20)
  • Margherita ($24.95), Neapolitan white pie ($22) and specialty pies like the Nino’s Special ($25.95)

Check out everything on the Nino’s menu and find your next favorite.

NY Style vs Sicilian Pizza: Common Questions

Q: What’s the difference between NY style and Sicilian pizza?

A: It mostly comes down to thickness and shape. NY-style is thin, round and foldable. Sicilian is thick, square and bready, a lot like focaccia. NY-style is the everyday pick. Sicilian is heartier and great for groups.

Q: What’s Grandma pizza, and how’s it different from Sicilian?

A: Grandma pizza is a Long Island original. It’s much thinner than Sicilian, with a crunchier bottom from the oiled pan. Sicilian is thicker and softer. Both are square, but they eat very differently.

Q: What are the main New York pizza types?

A: On Long Island you’ll mostly see NY-style, Sicilian and Grandma. Neapolitan and Detroit-style are getting more popular too. Each has its own crust, sauce and cheese.

Q: Does Nino’s Pizzeria in Patchogue have Sicilian pizza?

A: Yes. Our Cheese Siciliana is $23.95 for a whole pie, and you can grab a Sicilian slice for $3.50. See the full Nino’s menu for everything else we make.

Q: Can I get a pizza that’s half NY-style, half Sicilian?

A: Not really. They use different doughs and bake differently. You can always get one of each and taste them side by side, though. That’s the best way to settle the NY style vs Sicilian debate for yourself.

What We Make at Nino’s

Here’s a quick look at the styles you can order from us:

  • NY-style round pies with your choice of toppings
  • Cheese Siciliana and Grandma pie
  • Specialty pies. Call and ask what’s on the menu.

Come Hungry

Nino’s Pizzeria is at 580 Medford Ave in Patchogue, just off Route 112. Order online at orderninospizzeriamenu.com and get 5% off, or call (631) 654-4530. You can dine in, take out or get delivery.

Come eat with us

Dine in at 580 Medford Ave, or order for pickup and delivery across Patchogue.

580 Medford Ave · Patchogue, NY 11772

Call Order · 5% Off