Medford NY takes its pizza seriously. With a mix of NY transplants, longtime Long Islanders, and families who know what real pizza is supposed to taste like, every pizzeria has to show up with the real thing — or people just don’t come back.
If you’re searching for the best pizza in Medford NY, here’s an honest look at what locals actually care about, what the local pizza scene looks like, and where to get a real NY-style slice delivered hot to your door.
What Makes the Best Pizza in Medford NY
Fresh Dough, Every Day
The tell-tale sign of a great pizzeria: they mix their dough fresh every morning. No pre-made shells, no frozen bases. You can taste the difference on the first bite — and Medford locals absolutely notice.
Real Cheese, Not Processed
Whole-milk mozzarella, not the shredded pre-packaged stuff. The best pizza in Medford NY has cheese that melts into the sauce, not sits on top like rubber.
Sauce That Tastes Like Tomatoes
Not sweet, not overly herby — just bright, simple, real tomato flavor. A great sauce lets the crust and cheese do the work. Too much sugar is a red flag.
The Right Oven Temperature
Authentic NY-style pizza needs a hot oven — 600°F minimum. That’s what crisps the crust while keeping the inside perfectly chewy.
Friendly, Neighborhood Service
Medford’s a community. The best local pizzerias know your face. If the people behind the counter don’t smile when you walk in, it’s not a neighborhood spot — it’s just a transaction.
The Medford NY Pizza Scene — An Honest Overview
When you’re looking for the best pizza in Medford NY, you’ve got a few options ranging from chain delivery to full-service Italian kitchens.
Chain Pizza in Medford NY
Domino’s, Papa John’s, Pizza Hut — they’re there if you want something fast and predictable. But ask any Long Island local: chain pizza isn’t pizza, it’s pizza-shaped food.
Local Pizzerias in and Near Medford NY
Medford has a handful of local spots, and nearby Patchogue carries some of the best pies on Long Island. Because Medford and Patchogue sit so close together, many Medford residents regularly cross the town line for a significantly better slice.
Why Medford Locals Head to Patchogue for the Best Pizza
Patchogue — just minutes from most of Medford NY — is home to some of the most established, highest-rated pizzerias in the region. Nino’s Pizzeria, located on Medford Avenue in Patchogue, is consistently one of the top-rated pizza options for Medford residents, and delivers to Medford every single day.
Nino’s Pizzeria — The Best Pizza Near Medford NY
4.5 Stars, 259+ Google Reviews
With 259+ Google reviews averaging 4.5 stars, Nino’s ranks among the top pizzerias in the entire Patchogue-Medford area — not by accident, but by consistently delivering the real thing.
We Deliver to All of Medford NY 11763
Every neighborhood in Medford, NY 11763 is in our delivery zone. Typical delivery time: 30 minutes or less.
Real NY-Style, Made Fresh Daily
Thin, hand-tossed, crispy at the edge, chewy in the middle. This is how NY-style pizza has been made for generations — and it’s exactly what Medford locals expect.
A Full Italian Kitchen, Not Just Pizza
Pasta, calzones, wraps, salads, wings, and desserts — Nino’s is a complete Italian kitchen. Whether you’re feeding the family or ordering for a group, the full menu has you covered.
Most Popular Pizzas for Medford NY Customers
Classic Cheese — Medford’s Favorite
The simplest things done right: fresh dough, whole-milk mozzarella, our bright tomato sauce. A staple for a reason. Small $18.95 / Large $25.95
Pepperoni — The Game-Day Classic
Crispy edges, melted cheese, real pepperoni that curls into little cups of flavor. A crowd-pleaser every time. Small $18.95 / Large $25.95
Sicilian Cheese Pie — Thick and Loaded
Thick, fluffy, crispy on the bottom, topped with mozzarella, artichokes, roasted red peppers, ricotta, and basil pesto. This one earns its own category. Small $18.95 / Large $23.95
Extra Cheese — For the Cheese Lovers
Loaded with whole-milk mozzarella. No apologies. Small $18.95 / Large $25.95
How to Order the Best Pizza in Medford NY from Nino’s
- Online: orderninospizzeriamenu.com
- Phone: (631) 654-4530
- Pickup: 580 Medford Ave, Patchogue — approximately 10–15 minutes from most of Medford NY
Medford Delivery Times
From our kitchen to your door in Medford — typical timing:
- West Medford (near Patchogue border): 20-25 min
- Central Medford: 25-30 min
- East Medford / near LIRR station: 30-35 min
- Friday/Saturday 6-8 PM: add 10 min for peak times
Hungry Yet?
Nino’s Pizzeria is right here in Patchogue at 580 Medford Ave. Order online at orderninospizzeriamenu.com, call (631) 654-4530, or walk in. We deliver hot across Patchogue, Medford, Bellport, Bayport, Blue Point, Sayville, and East Patchogue.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s the best pizzeria in Medford, NY?
A: Opinions vary, but Nino’s Pizzeria — located just over the Medford line in Patchogue — is a top-rated option with 4.5 stars and 259+ reviews. We deliver throughout Medford daily.
Q: Does Nino’s Pizzeria deliver to Medford?
A: Yes. We deliver to all Medford neighborhoods, typically within 30 minutes.
Q: What’s the best time to order pizza for delivery to Medford?
A: Any time we’re open. Friday and Saturday 6-8 PM are peak; order 30 min ahead to avoid waits.
Q: Is Medford’s pizza NY-style?
A: The best pizza in the Medford area — including Nino’s — is classic NY-style: thin crust, hand-tossed, foldable slices, real mozzarella.