Blogs
Best Pizza in Medford, NY — Top Spots Reviewed by Locals
May 19, 2026 ◆ 4 min read ◆ Nino’s Pizzeria
People in Medford take their pizza seriously. You’ve got New York City transplants, lifelong Long Islanders and families who know what a good slice is supposed to taste like. If a place doesn’t deliver on that, folks just don’t come back.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Medford NY, here’s our honest take on what people around here actually care about, what your options look like and how to get a NY-style pie from us just over the line in Patchogue.
What Makes the Best Pizza in Medford NY
Everybody’s got their own favorite. Still, most people judge a pizzeria on the same few things.
Good dough
The crust is the foundation. A good one has some chew, a little crisp on the bottom and enough flavor that you’ll eat the edges instead of leaving them in the box.
Cheese that melts right
You want cheese that melts into the sauce and stretches when you pull a slice. It shouldn’t sit on top like a sheet of rubber.
Sauce that tastes like tomatoes
Not too sweet. Not buried in herbs. Just bright tomato flavor that lets the crust and cheese do their job. A sauce that tastes like sugar is a bad sign.
A hot oven
As a general rule, NY-style pizza bakes in a very hot oven, usually 500 to 600 degrees or more. That heat is what crisps the bottom and keeps the inside soft.
Friendly service
Medford’s a neighborhood. A good local pizzeria treats you like one of the regulars, even on your first visit. If nobody says hello when you walk in, that tells you something.
Pizza Options Around Medford NY
If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Medford NY, you’ve got a few kinds of places to pick from.
Chain pizza
Domino’s, Papa John’s and Pizza Hut are around if you want something quick and familiar. Plenty of people like knowing exactly what they’ll get. A local pizzeria is a different kind of meal, though.
Local pizzerias in and near Medford
Medford has its own local spots, and Patchogue is right next door. Since the two towns sit so close together, a lot of Medford folks don’t think twice about crossing the line for a slice.
Why Medford Folks Come to Patchogue for Pizza
Patchogue is just a short drive from most of Medford. Nino’s Pizzeria is at 580 Medford Ave in Patchogue, just off Route 112, so it’s an easy trip for a lot of Medford families. You can dine in, pick up, or order delivery. Call to check delivery to your address.
Nino’s Pizzeria, Right Near Medford NY
Easy to find
We’re on Medford Ave, just off Route 112. Open Monday through Saturday 11am to 9:30pm, and Sunday 12pm to 9:30pm.
Delivery to Medford
We do delivery, but whether we reach your street depends on where you are. Give us a call at (631) 654-4530 and we’ll tell you if we can get to your address.
NY-style pizza
Round pies, Sicilian, Grandma, white pies and slices. It’s the kind of pizza people on Long Island grew up on.
More than pizza
We’ve got pasta, heroes, wraps, salads, wings and desserts too. Take a look at the full Nino’s menu before you order. If you’re feeding a group, there’s plenty to choose from.
Pizzas Medford Customers Order Most
Classic cheese
Sauce, cheese and crust. Simple, and it’s a staple for a reason. $16.95
Pepperoni
Crispy edges and pepperoni that curls up in the oven. It’s always a safe bet for a crowd. Most one-topping pies are $18.95.
Cheese Siciliana
Thick, square and crisp on the bottom. If you like a heartier slice, this is the one. $23.95
Extra cheese
For the cheese lovers. Just ask for it on any pie when you order, and check the online menu for the current price.
How to Order the Best Pizza in Medford NY From Nino’s
- Online: orderninospizzeriamenu.com (5% off when you order online)
- Phone: (631) 654-4530
- Pickup: 580 Medford Ave, Patchogue, a short drive from most of Medford
Delivery to Medford
We don’t want to promise a time we can’t keep. Delivery depends on your address and how busy the night is. Friday and Saturday evenings tend to be our busiest, so ordering a little early helps. Call us and we’ll let you know if we deliver to you.
Hungry?
Nino’s Pizzeria is right here in Patchogue at 580 Medford Ave. Stop in, grab a slice, or call ahead for pickup.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What’s the best pizzeria in Medford, NY?
A: That’s up to you, and everybody’s got a favorite. We’d love for you to try us. We’re just over the Medford line on Medford Ave in Patchogue.
Q: Does Nino’s Pizzeria deliver to Medford?
A: We do delivery, but it depends on your address. Call (631) 654-4530 to check delivery to your address.
Q: When’s the best time to order for delivery?
A: Any time we’re open. Friday and Saturday evenings are busy, so ordering a little ahead is a good idea.
Q: Is the pizza around Medford NY-style?
A: Mostly, yes. Long Island pizzerias tend to make classic NY-style pies with thin, foldable slices, and that’s what you’ll find at Nino’s too.
Ready to eat? Order online at orderninospizzeriamenu.com and save 5%, or call us at (631) 654-4530.